Testing The Trainers: Insanity
Hey there. It’s time for another Testing The Trainers and this time I’m reviewing INSANITY, an in-home DVD workout program with bloodlines similar to P90X that’s got quite a following. Actually, Team Beach Body produces both systems; a company that seems to be pumping (pun intended) out workout DVD’s like mad. But can Insanity live up to its big brother’s name, and produce results similar to Tony Horton’s system?
My goal with these posts is to review the fitness program marketplace and give you the thumbs up (or down) on ones that I believe have merit as part of your fitness program. This way, YOU can create your own program. That’s exactly how I develop my own workouts and so should you. No one program is perfect, but by having knowledge on particular systems, you can decide how and what you want to do.
Insanity is led by Shaun T, whose resume is impressive. He’s a choreographer that’s worked with A list celebrities, appeared on various TV shows, and while studying dance and theater also received a BS in Sports Science. Plus he’s created various infomercial workouts, ranging from a dancing abs workout, to kids’ and preteen programs. He’s a busy guy! And INSANITY has him traveling the talk show circuit, making appearances on Ellen, CNN, and the now defunct Tyra Banks show. But you all know how I feel about celebrity endorsements – so is the program itself up to scratch?
Truthfully, I hated Shaun T’s Hip Hop Abs program and the promises it made. I still remember watching the infomercial and getting pissed when he’d tell people that dancing would give them a six-pack.
BUT, I have to say that INSANITY is thankfully nothing like its Saturday Night Fever fitness predecessor. Like P90X it, comes with various DVD’s, each targeting a specific part of the body or type of movement. Plyometrics, cardio, abs, and a fit test DVD are just a few of the 10 supplied videos. And again being a Beach Body product, it comes with a nutrition guide and 24/7 support. It’s a fairly complete package that when applied, can help improve your fitness. So far so good right?
Well, again I hate to keep comparing it to P90X, but some of the movements are risky for the average person. Although I must say that Shaun T reiterates over and over again the importance of form, listening to your body and being aware of pain and offering up some other important tips that you don’t always hear from a DVD system. So that’s very refreshing. I’m not saying that you will be injured, but without Shaun T, myself, or another competent trainer showing you and correcting your form on various movements, the risk of injury grows. Especially if you are a new trainee – all it takes is one wrong move.
Case in point – I watched several You Tube “success story” videos of people who taped themselves using the program… and was horrified! Their knee placement was all wrong, they hunched their lower back, they had bad form on jumps, lunges and even pushups.
Now they did get it done, and as Shaun T says, they “Dug Deep” – just with bad form. Did they make progress? Sure. Did they look and feel better? You bet. But I’d still like for them to do it the right way. So that aspect concerns me. As you know, I’m a stickler for exercise form, as it directly relates to function.
My biggest issue with this program is that it doesn’t contain any true strength training outside of using your own body weight. That’s not to say that there isn’t a benefit from using INSANITY, or that it’s not hard and challenging. But to truly reap the benefits of strength training (added lean muscle mass, osteoporosis prevention, higher metabolic rate) external resistance has to be used. It’s a scientifically proven fact, that body weight training, no matter how hard it is, will not produce the same results as using dumbbells, resistance bands and other forms of added resistance. It just can’t.
So here’s my thoughts – I like Shaun T and his program. He’s very charismatic which is of extreme importance when trying to motivate people to exercise. They have to believe the trainer actually has passion for their system and clearly he does. INSANITY is tough; really tough – I’m not arguing that point at all. And while it may be a bit gimmicky with claims of “flipping high intensity on it’s head”, or making it sound like he’s created a revolutionary way of training, it’s really just a kick ass, take no prisoners workout.
Why? Because it follows a simple premise that I’ve spoken about for years – Bust Your Ass! Period. Leave it all on the gym floor and work hard. You’re working out to become fit, and a better, healthier version of yourself. What you put in, is what you get out and INSANITY demands that you go “all in”.
I would like to see people who purchase this program run through it with a qualified personal trainer, just to make sure their form is on par. And because I’m a huge believer in the importance of true weight training, I’d suggest users also incorporate some straight weight training. All in all, I like INSANITY, it’s a great program, it looks fun, motivating, challenging and it will get results. How could it not? I believe the claims of burning up to 1000 calories an hour are true. Plus, I just like the name!
When it comes to Shaun T’s INSANITY
The Angry Trainer says RECOMMENDED!
|Print article||This entry was posted by Alfonso on March 24, 2011 at 4:29 pm, and is filed under TRAINING. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site.|
about 8 months ago - 7 comments
Time for another ATF Classic here on the site and this one’s a topic that I’ve come back to time and time again since we first launched the site… I’m always stunned that so many people in the fitness world still think there’s a clear difference between ‘weight training’ and ‘cardio training’. So they…
about 1 year ago - 3 comments
The infomercial market shows no signs of slowing down, so it appears I’ll have a job for quite some time here at Angry Trainer Fitness. Today’s Testing The Trainers features Mari Winsor and her ‘incredible’ Slimming Pilates program. I’ve seen the ads on TV for years and truthfully just shrugged them off – but does…
about 1 year ago - 12 comments
Here we go again with another Testing The Trainers, where I break down a popular exercise program and give you my take. In my opinion does the workout work, or is it worthless? Beach Body, the company that brought us P90X, Insanity, and Turbo Jam is at it again. This program’s called the Brazil…
about 2 years ago - 2 comments
Hey everyone! You may remember a few weeks back I gave you my Top 10: Healthy Cooking Tips. Hopefully you picked up a few tips from that one and are preparing healthier meals. Well today I’m going to present the flipside to my piece and tell you what I believe to be the Top Ten…
about 2 years ago - No comments
Hi Alfonso, I’m wondering what your thoughts are on calorie counting? Do you believe calorie counting is necessary for people to stay at their preferred weight? I’ve counted calories and it’s always frustrating to me. Almost as if I’m a failure for not being able to just eat the right amounts of food for fuel.…
about 2 years ago - 7 comments
In my recent “Are All Calories Created Equal” post, I discussed how important it was to understand the quality of various calories, their benefits, and how to use them in an intelligent eating regimen. As my piece made clear – no, not all calories are created equal. Guess what? The same holds true when it…
about 2 years ago - 10 comments
Hi Alfonso, I really enjoy your site! Thanks for keeping it simple and straightforward. My question is this: how late should I eat? I have heard that you should eat about 2-3 hours before you go to sleep. I have also heard that you should eat when you’re hungry. For me the two conflict sometimes.…
about 2 years ago - 1 comment
As I’ve said before, things are moving along nicely here at Angry Trainer Fitness as more and more people embrace our message and goals. Yesterday, my site producer Richard and I had a meeting in Manhattan with another well known fitness brand that we’re partnering with – more news on that one soon! But while…
about 2 years ago - 9 comments
It’s Top 10 time again and today I’m going to give you some simple tips that you can use to make healthier versions of the foods you love to eat. Believe it or not, you can drastically reduce the calories and fat within each meal by making just a few tweaks when preparing your meals.…
about 2 years ago - No comments
For the last twenty years I’ve been a personal trainer. For much of that time I’ve traveled to client’s houses in nearby counties, sometimes arriving as early as 4:45 am. Needless to say, having to always cook and prepare meals the night before became monotonous and sometimes I was just too tired or simply didn’t…